Wednesday, May 30, 2007

Celebrating diversity

I was looking at a job description for a Research Fellow in the Health Technology Unit at the University of Canterbury. I came across the following requirement:

Personal characteristics for this position include:
• Tolerance – acceptance, indeed celebration of diversity in relation to ethnicity, culture, values, religion and life choices.
This was the first of the personal characteristics mentioned.

What appears to me here is a new definition of "tolerance."

Back in the good old days - tolerance may have meant "put up with" - a rather passive definition. Someone who was tolerant of someone else may have simply "agreed to disagree." However, it now seems that passivity is not enough but action, celebratory action at that, is required.

This is a further example of changes in language that have attached to them expected patterns of behaviour.

What I see here is a move from "respect" to "tolerance" and now to "celebrate diversity"

As a Christian I attempt to respect people of other religions - after all I believe they are all created in the image of God and are loved by Him.

I tolerate their espousing of their religious views in public. Freedom of speech is a value I hold dearly.

I do not, however, tolerate the fact that they are espousing views that are in contradiction to the basic tenets of my religion. I do not tolerate the view that there is no god or more than one god, I do not tolerate the view that Jesus was just a prophet (and no more). These views are insults to God whom I worship.

Similarly, I do not expect people from other religions to tolerate the views I have.

The mere fact that we are intolerant of each other's views, is the point at which we can begin dialogue. It is not, as some would have us believe, a bad thing - it does not lead us all into terrorist acts!

To now suggest I should celebrate diversity in relation to religion is an appalling imposition on my most basic beliefs. It is insulting. I imagine it would be highly insulting to a Muslim and to many others of other religions.

I am a Christian and I can not, will not, celebrate the fact that there are others who do not yet know of the saving grace of Jesus Christ. To do so, would be to deny God.

For those for whom this is all a bit much ... consider this. Imagine if in order to obtain a job at the University of Canterbury you were expected to celebrate the diversity of sporting teams - it you were to celebrate when the Auckland Blues beat the Canterbury Crusaders!

A further illustration of how ridiculous this definition of tolerance is, consider that "celebrating diversity in life choices", must, by definition, celebrate the choice of a petty vandal who smashed my car window, or the choice of so many parents to feed themselves and their children appalling amounts of junk food so that their children will be diabetics for life and die at an early age without getting near to achieving the potential they were born with.

Oh, by the way .. for the apologist ... of course this is a typical example postmodern of the pot calling the kettle black. Would the writer of the statement quoted above please stand up and state that they wish to celebrate my religious position and life choice?

Whilst we are talking about diversity, when and how did it become a value rather than a statement of fact? In the new draft curriculum released by the Ministry of Education last year it was listed as a value to be taught in our schools. From my perspective diversity is no value, it is merely a word used to describe a situation. I happen to enjoy the greater diversity in ethnicities present in Christchurch now than 20 years ago. I do not enjoy the greater diversity in advertising.

Whilst we are on how some words have changed meaning - consider Prime Minister Clarke's use of the language on the radio this morning ..

"Genuine dialogue" - this was dialogue that took place within a meeting as opposed to dialogue that took place between those opposed to what was being discussed in the meeting and others. ie, it is Genuine because the PM said so!

"Extremism of any kind is not good for our world" followed shortly by "Extreme Fundamentalism" - in the context she was essentially putting Destiny Church, Muslim Terrorists, and Gordon Copeland (a gentle if deluded man) into the same basket.

If you want an interesting discussion on the use of the word Fundamentalism, have a look at this article by David Lindsay.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/category/story.cfm?c_id=301&objectid=10439506

Monday, May 28, 2007

DotCom 8: Assumptions at Pentecost

It's Pentecost and inevitably talk turns to talk about the Holy Spirit (rightly so). Over the past few weeks I've heard some teaching on the Holy Spirit, read some books and had several discussions. I have detected that most people (including myself) make assumptions about the Holy Spirit without really checking out the scriptures or thinking things through well. I've listed some of the assumptions I've detected. I'm uncomfortable with most of them (at least without them being qualified in some reasonable way), and I believe some are simply false and misleading. They are in no particular order ...

Assumption 1: A church is somehow inadequate if it does not demonstrate ALL of the gifts of the Holy Spirit mentioned in the New Testament. This assumption fails to recognise that we no longer live in the first centuary and that the Holy Spirit is quite capable of deciding which gifts are needed for which church in any given situation.

Assumption 2a: We should have the same experiences as at Pentecost as outlined in Acts 2.
Assumption 2b: We can have the same experiences as at Pentecost as outlined in Acts 2.
I definitely disagree with 2a. The coming of the Holy Spirit on that first Pentecost following Jesus' ascension was definitely a one off event. There is no biblical warrent to suggest that He came again with sound like a violent wind and what seemed to be tounges of fire and that we should expect that.
The Holy Spirit is sovereign, so I guess assumption 2b is correct - but I don't think we should be looking for those experiences.

Assumption 3a: Individuals have some how "missed out" on the Holy Spirit if they have not had certain experiences of one of the "manifestations" of the Holy Spirit.
Assumption 3b: Individuals have some how "missed out" on a special blessing of the Holy Spirit if they have not had certain experiences of one of the "manifestations" of the Holy Spirit.
3a is anathema to me. It smacks of the "two stage" initiation that is preached by the Roman Catholics and by some Pentecostal groups. To the contratry - Romans 8 (for example) categorically says to me that ALL Christians receive (are baptised in/by) the Holy Spirit when they repent and accept Christ's forgiveness. Two arguments are given in favour of 3a - one the disciples experience of first believing Christ and then, at Pentecost, receiving the Spirit. This is a false argument because - when they first believed the Spirit - living in Jesus - was right their with them and had not yet been released for the whole church. ie we are "post-Pentecost". The second argument is because of the story in Acts 8 which suggests that although the Samarians' believed in Jesus, they only received the Spirit after Peter and John came. I'm happy to take the story at face value. However, the writer, Luke, was clearly surprised at this (it was certainly not part of his normal experience as a companion of Paul). It is clearly not the norm - it is an experience not repeated in the NT. We should not take it as a norm for now. One cavaet - it appears God had a special reason to hact as he did (probably conected to being the first preaching out of Jerusalem and to a group previously antagonistic towards Jews). I must bow to the sovereignty of God and recognise that in special circumstances God could do the same again.

Assumption 4: Being like the NT church means experiences exactly what they experienced. No - we are in a different time and place and we, unlike they, have the benefit of all the NT writings ....

Assumption 5a: The Holy Spirit can be called into "being present" by impassioned pleas. No - he is already present in every Christian
Assumption 5b: The Holy Spirit can be called to manifest himself in certain (spectacular) ways by impassioned pleas. No - he is sovereign.
Having said this - the desire to feel closer to God through experiencing certain manifestations of the Spirit is an entirely reasonable and human desire. What is not reasonable is to rest our faith only on these experiences or to think we can some how order the Spirit around with "Come Holy Spirit Come ..." We need to be careful about the difference between expressing desire and commanding.

Assumption 6: The gifts of the Holy Spirit are limited to those identifiable in the New Testament. I don't see that Peter or Paul teach that the gifts they talk about are the only ones. I think they use a few lists as illustrative of the gifts. My suspicion are that there are many many more and that we, as a church, could do a lot more in affirming everyone's gifts - music, IT skills, research, business acumen.... again, I see we need to let the Holy Spirit be sovereign and not try and limit Him to certain activities or giftings.

Assumption 7: A gift belongs to an individual. This is a point of emphasis that is sometimes lost - I think all teaching about the gifts must put them in the Biblical context as gifts given to individuals in order to build up the church. The church's mission should be front and centre.

Assumption 8: The Holy Spirit is somehow more present when there are particular manifestations (toungues, prophecies, miracles) on show. I can't find any Biblical warrent for this, but it is an impression that is often given (even inadvertantly) at this time of year. The Holy Spirit is always present in all Christians. We do not get "more" or "less" of the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit is a person not a liquid - He can not be divided.

Assumption 9: Having an apparently supernatural experience in a Christian gathering is a guarantee of the prescence and action of the Holy Spirit. How I wish this was true! Unfortunately, all the gifts can be counterfieted - in fact it is likely that they were all on display amongst the pagans in Corinth. What is important is that in the actions of those present and in their future actions the fruit of the Spirit is displayed and that their teaching seeks to teach the truth at all times.

Assumption 10: I am somehow unworthy of having a gift of the Holy Spirity. No - God's grace is greater - he gives as he chooses and he has promised he always chooses to give ...

Assumption 11: Once I have a gift I'll always have it. I'm not convinced this assumption is true. Once again I come down to God's sovereignty. I believe in my own life I have been given gifts in words of wisdom and pastoring at times, but not at all times. Other gifts have stayed with me for a long time and are probably around which I should build my contribution to the growth of the church.

Wednesday, May 09, 2007

Herod, Joesphus and Jesus

An Israeli archeologist has found King Herod's tomb - http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6633979.stm

This it the "King" appointed by Rome to rule over Judea from about 37 to 4 BC. He was the one responsible for the killing of baby boys - the action that led Jospeh and Mary to take Jesus to Egypt.

What is interesting about this account is that
"It was an ancient staircase built for Herod's funeral procession - described in
detail by First Century historian Josephus Flavius - that led Prof Netzer's
team
to the hill-top burial site.
'The monumental stairs were built
specifically
for the funeral,' Prof Netzer said."

From a Christian apologetic point of view it is very interesting that the writings of Josephus Flavius (not a Christian, a historian writing in the first century AD) have proved reliable in this case. Does this not add some weight to what else Josephus Flavius writes about, namely:

  1. Jesus was "called Christ"
  2. James was his brother (and was stoned)
  3. Herod Agrippa dies suddently [c/- Acts 12:19-23]
  4. Herod Antipas killed John the Baptist
  5. Jesus was a wise man
  6. Jesus did suprising feats
  7. Jesus was a teacher
  8. Jesus led away Jews and Greeks
  9. Pilate condemned Jesus to the cross
  10. Jesus was impeached by high standing Jews
  11. Jesus' following continued after his death (and until when Josephus wrote this in about 90AD)

Also - with some dispute amongst scholars as to Josephus really saying the following (he was apparently anti-Christian ):

  1. Jesus was more than just a man
  2. Jesus was the Christ
  3. Jesus appeared on the thrid day (after his crucifixion0 alive again.

Tuesday, May 08, 2007

DotCom 7: Who do you say I am? Part II

Your homework

Find out who your friends, colleagues, family say Jesus is? (Christians and non-Christians).

s59 and all that

Confusion reigns over the s59 amendment bill – I have been hearing things on the media that are plainly wrong (eg Rhema saying that the bill had passed). I also have realised that if anyone is to enter public debate about this and other issues there is a need for them to understand the process into how an idea ends up law. Please feel free to pass this on if you think it of help to others …

I’ll try not to muddy the waters more, rather I thought I’d give some context (I’d like to claim to be totally unbiased … but that’s not possible) … so here goes ….

The history

How the bill may become law
Sue Bradford put into the ballot a “members bill” to remove the defence of “reasonable force” which parents (and no one else) were able to use if charged with assault of a child. A Jury of our peers is expected to decide if the force used were reasonable or not.

That is she seeks to remove s59 from the Crimes Act which reads
s59 Domestic discipline
(1) Every parent of a child and, subject to subsection (3) of this section, every person in the place of the parent of a child is justified in using force by way of correction towards the child, if the force used is reasonable in the circumstances.

(2) The reasonableness of the force used is a question of fact.

(3) Nothing in subsection (1) of this section justifies the use of force towards a child in contravention of section 139A of the Education Act 1989.

The bill was drawn from the ballot and so it went into the parliamentary system. As a member sponsored bill, rather than a government sponsored bill, there are comparatively few days set aside for debate on it. These days are spread over many weeks. It has to go through the same process.

The process involves a first vote (the first reading). In this case, parliament voted in favour of it and it was sent to a “select committee.” There are many select committees in parliament. Each committee consists of a group MPs (but not Ministers) and their job is to get in experts, listen to them, and propose amendments to the law.

Sue Bradford’s Bill is called “Crimes (Substituted Section 59) Amendment Bill” [this is the new name – it had a name change part way through], It was given it’s first reading on 27 May 2005 and passed on to the Justice and Electoral Select Committee. The election intervened and the committee only heard and read submissions from about March 2006 onwards until they reported back in November 2006.

The results of the vote on the first reading:
Ayes 63 New Zealand Labour 51; New Zealand First 2 (Brown, Donnelly); Green Party 9; Māori Party 1.

Noes 54 New Zealand National 27; New Zealand First 11 (Catchpole, Gudgeon, Jones, McNair, Mark, Paraone, Perry, Peters J, Peters W, Stewart, Woolerton); ACT New Zealand 9; United Future 7.

NOTE: In the first reading debate it is clear that some voted for it just to have the bill debated publicly and looked at in select committee, not because they supported every part of it.

When all the committee agrees to a change it is entered into the bill. The bill is then voted for a second time. If it passes, it goes to the next stage in which all the MPs sit together in parliament in one big committee (horrors!). At this point any amendments offered by individuals are debated on and voted on one by one. This process can take weeks.

The second reading was on 21 Feb 2007.

At this point some parties [National, United Future, NZ First] had decided that this bill was to be a “conscience” vote (it individual members were free to choose which way they wanted to vote) and others [Labour, Maori, Act, Greens] decided that it was to be a party vote (ie individual members must vote according to what the party leadership decide). Note also, that there had been an election between the first and second readings, so there had been changes in the shape of parliament. Some parties now had more influence, some less.

Ayes 70 New Zealand Labour 49; New Zealand National 6 (Bennett P, Blue, Borrows, Hutchison, Power, Rich); New Zealand First 3 (Donnelly, Woolerton, Stewart); Green Party 6; Māori Party 4; United Future 1 (Dunne); Progressive 1

Noes 51 New Zealand National 42 (Ardern, Auchinvole, Bennett D, Blumsky, Brownlee, Carter D, Carter J, Clarkson, Coleman, Collins, Connell, Dean, English, Finlayson, Foss, Goodhew, Goudie, Groser, Guy, Hayes, Heatley, Henare, Key, King, McCully, Mapp, Peachey, Roy, Ryall, Shanks; Simich, Smith L, Smith N, te Heuheu, Tisch, Tolley, Tremain, Wagner, Wilkinson, Williamson, Wong, Worth) New Zealand First 4 (Peters, Mark, Paraone, Brown); United Future 2 (Turner, Copeland); ACT New Zealand 2; Independent: Field

The bill then went to the Committee of the whole house. IT IS STILL THERE with the third and final reading due in a couple of weeks (ie it is NOT law yet).

Finally, the bill is given a third overall vote (the third reading), if it is passed it becomes law as of the date in the bill that states when it becomes law.

Some of the amendments
An amendment by Taito Philip Field (Independent) for the law’s introduction to be delayed a month if it passes its final reading was agreed upon (He had amendments ranging from1 month to 50 months and by agreeing on the first, the rest were not debated – this was a delaying tactic).
An amendment by Judy Turner (United Future) for the issue to go to public referendum if it was not passed by more than 60% of MPs was defeated.
An amendment by Clayton Cosgrove (Labour) for the effect of changes to s59 to be reviewed in 2 years time was adopted
An amendment by Chester Burrows (National) defining reasonable force as ‘transitory and trifling discomfort’ has been proposed but not adopted as it has been superseded by the amendment proposed by Peter Dunne (UF) (but in effect hammered out by Clark and Key) that directs police to ignore any cases it deems “inconsequential and not in the public interest”. This amendment was adopted on Tuesday this week.

The final vote, if passed, will put the adopted amendments into law.

The debate and the emotion
Some of this is personal opinion – warning J

I am absolutely certain that no members of parliament want to see children abused. I am certain that they all want to see measures in place that reduce the number of horrendous cases where children have been killed or badly injured. Part of the debate is about whether this bill will have any effect whatsoever on reducing cases of serious abuse.

Part of the debate has also been about the criminalisation of parents (or not) if they smack a child. Gordon Copeland (United Future) asked a Queen’s Council lawyer to give an opinion on the current law. The QC concluded that a parent is always not guilty of an offence (unless they are hauled before a court and convicted of using “unreasonable force”). Others (including Sue Bradford and Helen Clark) have stated that parents are technically guilty of assault now under current law and so the proposed amendment does not change anything.

The clear public opinion is that parents do not want to be considered guilty of a crime (whether or not they ever end up in court) if they lightly smack their child or use force to put them in time out.

There has been a lot of rhetoric that has divided. Sue Bradford and supporters have continued to use words like “hit” and “beat” and not “pick up and put in time out” or “smack.” These are very emotional words and, understandably, they have resulted in a lot of strong “anti-Sue” reaction by those parents who don’t like to be called child beaters.

Also, the labelling of people with emotionally laden words has not been helpful – “liberal” “fundamentalist” “Religious right” etc.

The role of churches
This is personal opinion – warning J

In my opinion churches should get involved in (i) supporting parliamentarians who are trying to reduce the incidence of child abuse, (ii) supporting parents (obviously) (iii) praying for parliamentarians of ALL parties (not enough of this happens!!!!!) (iv) supporting the education of their parishioners about how parliament works (in my opinion too many Christians and indeed Christian leaders are very ignorant of what can and can’t be achieved in parliament and how it is achieved. This means their voice is less effective).

What I disagree with is
(i) if a church expresses theocratic tendencies. Ie – we know best how to run the country because God is on our side (sorry – but this is how Destiny behaves).
(ii) Church hierarchy trying to speak on behalf of members without having consulted with them first. I recognise that it is difficult because 100% agreement will never be reached. Generally I think it better for church leaders to speak about principals rather than specifics of a bill. I believe the Anglican Bishops were wrong to speak out as they did. I also think that whilst John’s comments in the Press this morning were all very interesting, I think it was unnecessary that these dissenting views be expressed in the public and secular media.
(iii) Church’s being deliberately confrontational (especially with one another). I think both the Ecumenical Church group led by Anglicans in Wellington and Destiny should front up and apologise to each other, and all churches in New Zealand for the awful division they demonstrated the other day. Jesus prayed for unity and we should work at it. We shouldn’t be naïve and think this means we agree with each other all the time. Unity, though, is to be worked on – especially and how we present ourselves as Christians to the rest of the country.


Where to from here?
The final reading will most likely adopt the bill with all MPs voting for it with the exclusion of both Act, 2 United Future, Taito Philip Field and 6 NZ First MPs whom I expect will continue to oppose it. It appears (but not certain) that if there are dissenting voices in Labour and National (which there are in both) then these voices will not be heard in the final vote because Labour definitely, and the indications are that National as well, are voting as a party. Whilst it is technically possible for an MP to vote against their own party they normally need permission to do so. Those who have asked for that in Labour have not been given it. It remains to be seen if the same thing will happen with the National MPs. An MP may still vote against their party without permission, however, they are likely to face severe consequences from the party (eg – losing their ministerial post, being excluded from the caucus meetings where decisions are made, being dropped as a candidate in their seat or from the list, in the next election).

It will become law a month later.

At some stage, in court with some parent accused of assaulting their child, it must be debated if the incident at hand was “inconsequential and not in the public interest.”

Possibly a referendum at the next election …
Referendum: Currently there is a citizens initiated petition going around sponsored by United Future board member and former MP Larry Baldock. The petition currently has 170,000 signatures. If it reaches 300,000 then the question is proposes must be put to the country next election day. As with all such questions they must be put in both the positive and negative so that people can decide if they support the repeal of the law or not. (ie it is a petition seeking to have a question asked at the next election, not a petition voicing opposition – so both people in favour of and opposed to the law change may sign it in the hope that they will have their say come next election).


Further reading:
Scoop: The Press Releases by parties and lobby groups: http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/HL0703/S00511.htm
How a Bill becomes law: http://www.parliament.nz/en-NZ/HowPWorks/Laws/7/5/6/75639197bdff4a15b57eaaade358509e.htm
Details of what was said in debates in parliament (Hansard reports) and the select committee report can be found at: http://www.parliament.nz/en-NZ/PB/Legislation/Bills/b/2/4/b24fba96f2224b1985bc254efac71c63.htm


Some of you know of my role in United Future as it’s Chair for Canterbury and Westland. Please note: The views expressed here are mine, not United Future’s.

Dr John Pickering
john@ie-nz.com
354 1424

DotCom 6: Who do you say I am? Part 1

Jesus asked his disciples about who people thought he was. Over the next couple of weeks we shall explore that question in our contemporary society.

First, let us dispel the myth that Jesus did not consider himself divine. There are many Biblical passages we could use for this (for example Paul's beautiful description of Jesus in Philippians 2). I've chosen to to use part of John's gospel.

One of the structures of John's gospel is the 7 "I am" statements.
6:35 I am the bread of life
8:12 I am the light of the world
10:7 I am the gate for the sheep
10:11 I am the good shepherd
11:25 I am the resurrection and the life
14:6 I am the way the truth and the life
15:1 I am the true vine

Each of these statements begin with "I am." (obviously). In Greek as in many languaegs today (eg Polish) there are two ways to say "I am", indeed two ways to express any verb. The reason is that the ending of the verb tells you if the meaning is "I" or "he, she, it, you, they". So the workd "eumi" in greek means "I am." However, if someone wants to emphasise the "I" then they can put the work for I in front of "eumi". That is they say "I Iam" (ego eumi). This is what John wrote was Jesus emphasis in all these statements. If he had spoken in English then we may have recognised the emphaise my the tone of voice "I am." John is making sure that the readers of know that Jesus was emphasising himself (singularly) in all all these statements.

But, wait, there's more.

Read
John 14:8-11 where Jesus explicity links himself to God the Father
10:30-31 where he is one with the Father
10:36 where he is recognized as the son of God
8:58-59 were he claims to pre-exist Abraham - "I tell you the truth, before Abraham was born, I am!"

8:59, 10:31,39 When the Jews heard what Jesus was saying they immediately, without hesitation, concluded he was blasphemeing and deserved to die. Why - because he explicitly identified himself as God because he used the Jew's special name for God. That name is "I am" (Yhwh, Jehovah in Hebrew). In Exodus 3:14 Moses asks God what his name is ... he answers "I AM WHO I AM".

The conclusion that John wanted his readers to draw is obvious - Jesus claimed to be the great I AM, the eternal creator God giver of life.

Friday, March 23, 2007

DotCom 5: The Gospel of Judas

I was asked what this was ...

It is a text of the second century that was written by a "gnostic" sect. The gnostics were a movement that claimed special "gnosis" - ie special knowledge - about Jesus Christ and God. Their teachings and writings (including the gospel of Judas) where rejected by church leaders at the time as a fabrication. With the recent publication of a translation of the gospel (the only known ancient copy) church leaders have continued to reject it. As it appears at around the same time as the Da Vinci Code, it, not surprisingly, has been seized on by various conspiratory theorists amongst others.

Wikipedia has a reasonable article about it here.

An English translation of the text can be viewed at here . you will notice the talk of secrets and mysteries (in this case revealed only to Judas supposedly).

DotCom 4: Church, why bother?

A good discussion was had by all on "Why bother with Church?"

We looked at Jesus' prayer in John 17 in which he:

Emphasised the oneness between himself and his Father

Emphasised the oneness amongst the Disciples

Emphasised the truth the disciples now hold ... the basis of the "Apostolic Church"

Emphasised his oneness with the people who where to believe in the future and linked he in them (and us) and him in God the Father.

Emphasised the unity the believers where to show so that others may know of his love.

From this we can conclude:
- The church is Apostoloic. ie it must be based on the teaching of the Apostles.
- The church must strive for unity
- The church exists as a witness - and it's unity is a central component to this
- The unity of the church is the same as the unity that Jesus shows with his Father
- The church will not fail, and we must not give up on it, simply because it is Jesus' choice of the way he wants himself revealed to the world.

Wednesday, March 07, 2007

Dotcom 3: How was the NT formed?

It's a good question. After all, we are making, and asking others to make, life changing decisions based on 2000 year old texts.

Ancient texts
Over 5000 ancient fragments and manuscripts of the NT remain.
The earliest of these was around 130AD (papyrus fragments of John 18). About another 85 papyri exist.
Manuscripts of most of the Gospels, Acts, Paul's letters, Hebrews and Revelations are from 200-250AD
Complete manuscripts of the NT from the 4th and 5th centuries have been preserved.

A few points to note:
The manuscripts are remarkably consistent with only a few minor variations that are small copiest errors.
The volume of manuscript evidence far outweighs that of any other ancient text. For example, Josephus wrote of the Jewish Wars in about 90AD. There is one Latin translation from the 5th century, and Greek copies from the 10th century or later available. There are 10 manuscripts of the Gallic Wars (58-50BC) by Caesar, all later than the 9th century.

Which books?
How did the 27 books of the NT come to be chosen as the "right ones" (called forming the canon of the NT)?

1. Letters from Bishops Clement (96AD), Ignatius (c.108AD) and Polycarp (c110AD) between them quote and refer to 25 of the 27 books.
2. In addition to the gospels the letters of Paul and other apostles where quickly recognised as valuable - some had been deliberately written for circulating amongst churches.
3. In the second century there arose some heretical movements (mainly Gnostics with beliefs such as the God of the OT being different from that of the NT, Christ's human appearance and suffering where not "real" etc). These groups tended to pick and choose what they wanted from the texts (sound familiar?) and some even wrote "Gospels" to fill in the childhood of Jesus, on add some additional "Acts" of the apostles.
4. Iraneus in about 190AD (who studied under Polycarp who had been a disciple of John) recognised the need to spell out which books were acceptable. This is largely what we recognised today as the NT but with Hebrews, 1&2 Peter, 3John missing. The Shepherd of Hermes was considered OK for private worship, but not public and the Wisdom of Solomon was included.
5. The Wisdom of Solomon was soon dropped, some specific books excluded (incl the Shepherd of Hermes and Revelation of Peter), and James, 2Peter, 2&3 John and Jude debated for a while before they were included by AD350-400.

The early Church followed Jesus lead in recognising the authority of the OT. They recognised the Gospels and most of the NT having similar authority very early on. The disputes were not over what should be included in the canon of the NT so that it would be authoritative, but what is authoritative and therefore should be included.

It was not simply one or two who sat down and made decisions, but a broad consensus over many decades as to what was and what was not authoritative. Some criteria were obvious - it had to be written or sponsored by an apostle, recognized as having orthodox content, and be widely in use in the churches.

Another point to recognise is that these texts survived the many persecutions of the church - in other words they were found to be relevant to the lives and sacrifices of the early Christians.

For those wanting to read some more, FF Bruce's "Documents of the New Testament; Are they reliable?" is a good place to start.

Wednesday, February 28, 2007

Dotcom 2: Was Jesus buried with his wife and son?

James Cameron, Hollywood producer, has claimed that some ossaries (boxes that once contained bones and were used in Israel to bury dead in about 2000 years ago) contained the remains of Jesus, of Mary of Magdalene (supposedly his wife) and of his son. He is claiming this is revolutionary. Here are some thoughts in response.

  • The claimant is a Hollywood producer with a film ready for release from which he stands to make a great deal of money
  • The film is coming out very shortly after the Da Vinci Code which was a runaway financial success based on the myth of Jesus' marriage
  • The claimant is not an Archaeologist - rather the Archaeologist who first studied these artefacts says the claim is nonesense (and, being a Jew, would have reason to support the claim)
  • The claim is made some 27 years after the discovery of the artefacts - why wait so long? ($?)
  • Archaeologists who have studied the artefacts on are not sure about the names on the inscriptions. Even if they are Jesus, Joseph, Marie, these were common Jewish names 2000 years ago and appear on other similar ossaries
  • The claimant has tried to suggest that he his claim (if true) does not destroy Christianity. He obviously fails to understand that without resurrection there is no hope and no Christianity.
  • In order for him to make this suggestion he must dismiss the mountains of manuscript evidence from eyewitnesses and others as to Jesus life, death and resurrection. That is, he is saying that 3 boxes with barely decipherable scratches provide greater certainty than all the Biblical texts put together
  • Furthermore, he is insinuating that the writers of the Gospels and NT letters where either lying about Jesus' resurrection or all mad. There is no evidence for either. Furthermore, they and many others were cruelly murdered for their belief in the death and resurrection of Jesus. An unlikely occurrence if they were lying (they had nothing to gain).
  • He is also insinuating that the NT writers somehow "forgot" to mention Jesus' marriage, or deliberately and assiduously failed to mention it. There appears to be no ancient belief that Jesus was married ... in fact the first suggestion that he was appeared around the 12th century.

Dotcom 1: What is the Bible?

What does it mean to say "I believe in the Bible" or that the Bible is the "Word of God"? Here are a few notes to stimulate your thinking ...

"I believe in the Bible" for me is a statement more about God than the books of the Bible. I am, in effect, saying God has authority and I sit under than authority. God has chosen to reveal himself to me through the Biblical story, therefore I better take note of it!

"The Bible is the inspired word of God." This is another cliche. In 2 tim 3:14-17 Paul uses a word sometimes translated as "inspired"
"All scripture is inspired by God ..." (NRSV translation)

In other translations it uses the term (closer to the Greek) of "God breathed" which reminded Timothy and us of God breathing life into Adam. So the Bible get's its life - it's very meaning - from God. This helps me because it reminds me that if I try and interpret any particular passage from the Bible I must remember that it's God who gave and gives it life. Any meaning I try and give it must be submitted to God for checking ... it must be consistant with the whole Bible (let the Bible interpret the Bible), with the Biblical Story (ie it must fit in with how God is trying to restore all people to himself) and with the character of God.

In the 2Tm passage mentioned Paul talks of "All Scripture" being profitable for teaching, rebuking, correcting, and training in righteousness. Interestingly he is speaking of what we now call the Old Testament. Amongst some people there is the temptation to read the New Testament only and a few selected parts (eg Psalms) of the OT. I think this warns us to take the scripture as a whole and not to neglect parts of it. It also tells us that it's purpose is to help make and keep me right with God so that I can do good work.

The Biblical story, therefore, is still being carried out in our lives as we are still part of God's story as we become more righteous, build the church, and await the completion of the story.

Literal v Liberal interpretations
I've noticed that there tends to be a polarisation in the mind of some that there are only two possible positions to take with respect to the Bible, namely: "Liberal" where what is interpreted from the Bible depends much on what is socially acceptable amongst the wider community of the day and "Literal" where every word of the Bible must have a concrete meaning relating directly to today. I believe both views are fundamentally flawed. The flaw being the same for both ... they tend to fail to take into account what the original writers and hearers/readers first understood with what was written. This way of interpreting the Bible is known as eisegesis. Simply put eisegesis is giving a meaning from outside with minimal regard to the original meaning. Some very liberal interpreters do that over moral issues - such as homosexuality, saying that because we know more now and we "should" accept homosexuals and that God is love that the passages in the Bible that condemn homosexual acts no longer apply. Similarly some literal interpreters will find in the Bible allegories to almost every modern situation (such as Barry Smith did with Revelations when he said the world would end in 1985).

The opposite of eisegesis is exegesis. Exegesis requires us to first understand what was written, by whom and for whom. We must see how that fits into the whole Biblical story and with the character of God. From that (Ex being "out of") we may draw conclusions as to what it may mean to us today. For me, exegesis is always the starting point.

I do, though, believe we should take a literal interpretation of the Bible in the sense that we should take a liberal interpretation of ALL we read. Namely, when I read a novel I take it literally as a made up story, when I read a set of instructions for a microwave I take them as instructions that must be followed, not re-interpreted as a myth, when I read a scientific text book I take it as science, or a poem as poetry. The same goes for the Bible - I read poetry as poetry, historical narrative as historical narrative, parable as parable, allegory as allegory etc.

So, when I approach a Bible passage I ask the questions:
"What genre?"
"What is the author's purpose?"
"Who were the audience?"
"How did they react?"
"Why is it in the Bible?"
"How does it fit with the Biblical story?"
"What does it tell be about God?"
and, only then
"What can it suggest to me about the world about me, about the church, about who God wants me to be?"

Monday, February 05, 2007

What are the questions?

In the previous post - "The hope that we have" I talked of some of the questions people have about Christ, the Church, your faith.

I'd like us to begin a discussion and help each other to provide answers to such questions. Please just post a question with some context and I'll do a bit of thinking and give an answer as a starting point for discussion.

John

Saturday, February 03, 2007

The hope that we have - 1 Peter

Place: St Christopher’s
Date and Time: 7pm. 5 Feb 2007.
Title: Apologetics

I wonder if any of these statements are familiar to you ….

“I believe all religions are the same …”
“Jesus was a good man, but …”
“Obviously it’s true for you, but don’t push it down my throat”
“Christianity is so intolerant …”
“How can God allow that little girl to die?”
“All truth is relative …”

I like the last one in particular because the obvious answer is “Are you absolutely sure?”

What comments have you heard?

When you or I respond to questions like this we are engaging in something called “Apologetics”, this comes from the Greek word Apologia which means to give a word back. It was used in biblical times for the response an accused gave in defence of themselves in court. For example, a Roman governor (Festus) in Acts (25:16) said that in line with Roman traditions Paul had the right to make an Apologia to his accusers “face to face.”

How many of you have been to an Alpha course?
How many have read some of CS Lewis?
How about having heard Ravi Zacharias on the radio or read one of his books?

If so, then you’ve benefited from some of the best apologists of the last 50 years. These people and others all help us understand the answers to some of the difficult questions
- “Where is God when it hurts?”
- “How can God allow evil?”
- “How can Christianity be so exclusive?”
etc.

It is not the apologetics of intellectual giants that I want to talk about today, but the apologetics that you and I are exhorted to engage in by Peter in his first letter where he wrote:

“Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have.” 1 Peter 3:15

Apologetics is the “give the reason” bit.

Peter was not writing to CS Lewis or Nicky Gumbell exclusively, but to Christians who, like us, a minority living amongst non-believers – pagans – who, at best were indifferent to them, at worse they hassled them.

CONTEXT


Peter was in probably in Rome and he was writing to Christians dispersed across what we not think of us North and East Turkey

It was a
•Fearful society (3:14) [Recall Paul in Athens who found an alter to an "unknown god" whom people offered sacfices to just in case this god got upset and caused them some problems!]
•Unrestrained society - drink and sex (4:3)
•Pluralistic society – idols (4:3)
•Hostile society to Christians
–Fiery ordeal (4:12)
–Maligned as evildoers (2:12)
–Considered shameful

This hostility was not from the Roman authorities (whom Peter told the Christians to honour), but from the locals. The exact nature of the persecution is uncertain but it appears to have involved a lot of false accusations – some of them quite serious. You may recall that Paul got in trouble with locals once when the local silversmiths got upset because his preaching diminished their trade in silver idols! They may have also been accused of things like cannibalism because of the communion ritual. In short, their suffering was because they were different, others were ignorant of what they were really about, and because of fear.


Another aspect of the society around them was that it was extremely concerned with showing honour to others - something that usually involved praising publicly the good deeds of others. They also were extremely concerned to avoid shame.

Peter reminds the Christians that their honour does not come from others, or the emperor, but through the genuiness of their faith and their behaviour during the siffering. In fact should they suffer for doing right (3;23) then it is to their honour and to the shame of those who persecute them.

PARALLELS

I see many parallels here with us and the society we live in …

Fearful

From yesterday's Press:

Dire climate warning
By PAUL GORMAN and PATRICK CREWDSON - The Press 05:00am
More violent floods and hurricanes, acute droughts and frequent heat-waves will plague the Earth if there are no massive reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, scientists say.


We are fearful – not so much of capricious Gods, but of what will happen to us and our planet. Will global warming “get us” as this Press article suggests.
Will it be terrorism?
Will we be destitute?
Will our friends still like us if we don’t get drunk with them?
Will he still like me if I don’t go to bed with him?
We are still a fearful society


Unrestrained

From yesterday's Press:

Alleged sex act by police officers
By STAFF REPORTERS - The Press 05:00am
Christchurch police are investigating allegations that two officers had sex outside a city station.

Such headlines should cause us shock, but they don't anymore because we are so used to a society which has seperated sex from love and revels in the debauchery involved.


Pluralistic

"Tolerance" is the new meta-religion.

Even our own church leaders have fallen for the myth that we must somehow show our tolerance by accepting other religions. Last year they allowed the erction of Buddhist statues on Cathedral property, and a Hindu text on an alter cloth.

Hostile

There are plenty who are publicly hostile to Christianity. One of the most vehement in recent times in Biologist and popular author who has not dropped all pretence of being a scientist and come out scathingly against the church in a new book called "The God Delusion" in which he
asserts the irrationality of belief in God and the grievous harm religion has inflicted on society, from the Crusades to 9/11.

On a local scale - I heard this mornign how a son-in-law had been preventing a grandmother from taking her 2 year old granddaughter to church.

You'll have your own stories of hostility.

PETER'S RESPONSE

You must Remeber (read the first chapter of 1 peter):

–Who you are in Christ – chosen, made holy (1:2)
–What God’s done – Prophets (1:10) – Jesus – New Birth (1:3)
–What God will do
•Inheritance – revealed in the “last time” (1:6)
•Give honour when Jesus returns (1:7)
•Fulfil our purpose – salvation of our souls (1:9)


Peter’s response was to remind everyone of who they where, what God has done and what God will do.
We live in a society that resists any overarching story (metanarrative) – a characteristic of postmodernism has been to reject the idea that anyone or any country can some how say how history really is.
We need to be reminded that God created, we messed up, and God put in a plan that peaked with Christ’s coming, but is yet to be fully played out.

In short

Christ has Died, Christ has Risen, Christ Will Come Again



and Peter continues

THEREFORE (we must ask what is it there for) prepare your minds for action.



In those days the mind was not centred in the brain but in the heart. When the Bible speaks of heart it is not speaking of passion or some ill defined feeling, but the core of our thinking that drives our behaviour.

What we put into our mind will ultimately come out of us – positively we focus on the promises of Christ – of Jesus coming again to right all wrongs, to bring us to completion in him
Negatively, we reject the ways of the fearful, pluralistic society around us and we set our lives aside for Christ. We are to be holy even as God is holy – a big call, but by the grace of God one we can strive towards every day of our lives.

In this way, Peter says, we will influence those around us – our friends, our bosses, our spouses. Even when some are hostile there will be questions to be answered and by preparing our minds for action we will be prepared to answer them.

Why should we be prepared?


I began talking of some of the things people say
“Jesus was a good man, but ….” “All truth is relative …” “Science has proved there is no God …” “If there is a God he wouldn’t have allowed …”
It is very tempting not to rock the boat and just ignore those comments. I can easily in my mind justify this by saying “Everyone is entitled to their own opinion “ (a postmodern cliché), or “God doesn’t need my help to defend the gospel”

This, though is very muddled thinking. We are asked to “give a reason” for two reasons

1. to prevent evil.

Today’s ideas are tomorrows actions, look at where some ideas led ...
–There is no God therefore everything is permissible (Nietzsche) – Hitler
–“Religion is the opiate of the masses” (Marx) – Stalin
– belief in God is not just wrong, but potentially deadly (Dawkins) - ????

Hitler was some one's grandson, he was someone's class mate, he was someone's work mate ... if one of them had managed to give him reasons for hope centred on Christ, how different history would be!

Who knows about those around you - they will be teachers, parents, and leaders. Are you ready to respond to them to prevent evil.

2. so that others too may have hope

We have no right to deny anyone hearing of the hope that we have. To the contrary for the sake of their souls – for the sake of their eternal life and all the other people they may come into contact with and may influence we must be prepared to speak of the hope that we have – of who we are in Christ, of Christ who has dies, Christ who has risen and Christ who will come again.

HOPE

Unlike lotto our hope is not pie in the sky – a “might”.
It is not individualistic, but for everyone.
Our hope is a certainty.
Our hope is based on Truth and the Truth shall set you free. One of the greatest challenges as a Church in New Zealand is to responds to a society that rejects absolute claims to truth. Personally, this is a challenge I have given myself – to try and understand the various subcultures of New Zealand and to find ways to respond to their questions with the truth. I am very interested in working with anyone else who wants to help me build bridges to convey the truth of the gospel and the hope that it brings.

The Challenge

Where do you place your hope?
Are you prepared?


Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have.

Thursday, November 02, 2006

S&C 4: The danger of scientific theology

We tend to think of an "ology" as a science - biology, psychology, cosmology. Certainly when we come to think about parts of the universe we turn to science and scientists for answers. We respect their ability to detach themselves from the object and study it dispassionately applying logic and tried and true techniques to find answers. Part of science, therefore, is to stand above the object - it is "arrogant" in the sense that the scientist is somehow "greater" than the object.
That is certainly the message that was passed down to us from the Enlightenment - the age of reason and it still pervades much of our thinking today.

The danger for the theologian, and indeed any Christian who thinks about God, is that we do so in the same "arrogant" scientific manner in which we project ourselves as somehow "greater" than the subject (God in this case). We see this happening with those who try and reconstruct Biblical texts to fit their own view of the way they think the world should be. We see it in our own lives when we try and manipulate God with "deals" (if I do this, you do that - like a scientific hypothesis - if I push this, then "that" will happen).

One of the good things that has come out of postmodernism is a degree of skepticism about the claims of science to have all the answers and to be totally independent. Postmodernism has reminded us that we are all interconnected - because we are all part of God's creation.

Monday, October 23, 2006

Labour day

Labour day today.

A thought .... paraphrased from the Westminister catchism of the Anglican church:

"Men and Women's chief end is to glorify themseleves and enjoy themselves for ever" or so think many of us. Our aim is to work in order to rest. What folly ... do we really want to spend 40 hrs a week for 40 years merely marking time waiting for weekends and retirement (which for most is a struggle anyway)? Can we really be satisfied with glorifying only ourselves. What a waste.

"Men and Women's chief end is to glorify their employer and to enjoy them for 2,000 hours a year" or so many of the economic theorists (and politicians) and not a few employers think. Just as we don't exist for ourselves, we are also not merely cogs in a machine - mere human resources, for the greater glory of GDP.

"Men and Women's chief end is to glorify God and [in so doing] enjoy Him [and ourselves' forever." This then is the context in which we live our lives - the work life balance we so seek is right because it acknowledges our creator and the purpose of our creation.

Sunday, October 15, 2006

Wholeness

I've thought a lot lately about responding to the whole of a person. As a chaplian I'm obviously interested in their spiritual wholeness. But, this can not be divorced from other needs - physical, social, psychological and financial.

I recall when I was involved in helping physical needs - developing a laser to remove birthmarks - that I was amazed at the transformation that could result in people with what could be classed as a cosmetic change. The man who used to work night shifts to avoid people ended up training to be a helicopter pilot - a life long dream. The elderly lady who had spent her life wearing a scarf on her face becoming the life of the party and telling everyone that "now I will live". Obviously there are more serious physical issues than birthmarks, but it is apparent to me that they all impact our psychological and spritual lives. This is one of the reasons I am building a business (using some laser technology again) that is aimed at helping prevent people getting degenerative diseases like cancers, heart disease and stroke. In doing so I have also seen the difficult financial situation so many people are in and how that can also affect their spiritual and physical health.

This has all reiterated to me the fact that we are not merely "bodies" nor merely "spirit" (psyche), nor, in fact, merely "human resources" - cogs in some economic machine. Being truley whole, therefore, is being fully physical, fully spritual, and in proper relationship to the world - including the economic system - in which we live.

For me personally - whether I am wearing my hat as a Chaplain or a businessman, or as a father, a son, a husband, or friend - I need to learn to treat people as whole human beings. Practically, this starts with listening to their needs and responding with compassion, wisdom ,a and grace - so help me God.

Tuesday, October 10, 2006

About the children

Children keep us focussed on what matters. I had a wonderful time with a blessing of a child care facility the other day. Here is a poem I wrote;


What is a child that your are mindful of her
and infant that you care?
Formed in their mother's womb under your watchful eye
Set apart as unique, never to be repeated
So fragile, yet so strong
Destined to love and be loved
Created with tears to wash away pain and
laughter to embrace all that is joyous and good
Ahhh... there is our answer
In a glimpse of innocence,
of unrestrained joy,
is a reflection of the divine.

Tuesday, September 26, 2006

Meaning

"God made life, and God alone can tell us its meaning."
J.I.Packer in "Laid-Back Religion"

Thursday, September 21, 2006

Self worth

When either through our own messing up or through someone else messing us up our self worth takes a hammering it is an opportunity to stop and ask the question "where is my self worth?" For many it is centred in what they do professionally - be as a student or in the work place. Our culture almost expects this, afterall one of the first questions asked of a new aquaintance is "what do you do?" with the answer expected to be in respect to their professional life. Unfortunately, our work and workplace can be a fragile environment dependent on personalities and economic forces. Is "what we do" really who we want to be?

As a Christian I must remind myself that my worth is that which has been gifted me by a loving God who thought me worth the sacrifice of a child for. Not that I have done or been anything so fantastic, just that I am the object of grace - underserved love. My self-worth is, therefore, God's worth.

I wonder what the reaction would be next time someone asks "what do you do?" if you answered "I love God and my neighbour"?

Even for those who don't hold to the Christain faith, would you answer "I am loved by my family and I love them in return."?

Sunday, September 17, 2006

Work 5: Role Models

The "Don Brash" affair in the media this week got me thinking about all of us who at one time or another are role models for others. If it becomes public that the coach of a junior football team is having an extramarital affair with the art teacher, or the principal is caught driving over the limit, should they resign?
Questions of honesty and integrity of those in leadership are important. Intentionally or otherwise these people are role models. Usually we claim "my private life is my own business" - but the boundaries between public and private blur when we are perceived to be people with traits we expect others, in particular children, to follow. Furthermore, we are one person - the person who is dishonest in their private life is the same person with the responsibility to be honest in their public working life.
However, none of us are perfect - and Jesus saying "let whoever is without sin cast the first stone" is a reminder to be absolutely fair in our judgment of others and their actions. I guess the place to begin is in looking at ourselves as individuals - in private and in public - and expecting of ourselves the same levels of honesty and integrity as we expect of our children, spouses, and friends.